12 Nov 2026 · Vietnam VI

Citizenship · Capital · Global Mobility

The Legation Times

Germany denies freelancers the founders’ three-year settlement route

Michael Mai Michael Mai
Aerial view of Berlin in hazy light: the Spree runs between apartment blocks and a brick bridge, with the television tower on the horizon

One clause in Germany's Residence Act denies freelancers the three-year route to settlement; the general route needs five years, 60 months of pension contributions or comparable provision, and other conditions.

Section 21(5) of Germany’s Residence Act says a foreigner may be granted a residence permit to practise a liberal profession, without the tests that paragraph 1 sets for company founders. The subsection ends with one sentence: “Absatz 4 ist nicht anzuwenden”, or “paragraph 4 does not apply”. That paragraph holds both the three-year limit on a self-employment permit and the path to settlement after three years.

What the sentence removes

Under section 21(4), a self-employment permit is limited to at most three years. After three years of self-employment a settlement permit may be granted ahead of the general rule, if the activity promises further sustainable development, income secures the livelihood of the holder and the dependent family, and the public-security condition is met. The founders’ route rests on that paragraph.

Federal administrative guidance from 2009 states that the privileged grant of a settlement permit under paragraph 4 is excluded for freelancers by law. The Federal Office for Migration and Refugees says the freelance permit’s duration depends on the purpose of stay, and that an unlimited right of residence can be obtained after five years.

The general route

Section 9(2) sets the conditions for the settlement permit: five years holding a residence permit, a secured livelihood, and at least 60 months of compulsory or voluntary contributions to the statutory pension insurance. The pension condition can also be met by proving expenditure for an entitlement to comparable benefits from an insurance or pension institution or an insurer. Career breaks for childcare or home care are credited accordingly.

The conditions also include no public-security or public-order grounds against settlement, the other permits needed to practise the activity permanently, sufficient German (level B1), basic knowledge of the legal and social order, and enough living space for the household. A completed integration course proves the German and the civic knowledge.

For spouses living together, one spouse meeting the pension, employment-permission and permit conditions is enough. Lawful stay on a national visa counts towards the five years.

Who counts as a freelancer

The visa handbook says the group of freelancers follows the catalogue in section 18(1) of the Income Tax Act. It covers independent scientific, artistic, literary, teaching and educational work, and independent professions such as doctors, lawyers, engineers, architects, tax advisers, journalists, interpreters and translators, “and similar professions”.

Section 21(5) says the permit “may” be granted. Federal guidance speaks of the exercise of discretion, gives the opinions of the bodies involved decisive weight, and says the permit may be granted only if the work is actually carried on as self-employment. The visa handbook has the mission check on its own responsibility whether the work is freelance or in substance employment.

Where a profession needs a licence, it must have been granted or promised. The expert bodies for the place of the planned work, the trade authorities, the public-law professional bodies and the licensing authorities are to take part in the examination. Recognition of foreign qualifications is necessary for regulated professions and not prescribed for others, and usually takes three to four months.

Money and age

The freelance clause applies “by way of derogation from paragraph 1”, which sets three tests for company founders: economic interest or regional need, positive effects on the economy, and financing secured by equity or a loan commitment. This means a freelancer does not have to meet those tests, though the general rule still requires a livelihood covered without public funds, health insurance included.

For applicants older than 45, the permit is as a rule granted only if they have adequate old-age provision, under section 21(3). The law sets no figure. Federal guidance asks the authority to make a forecast and lists assets in any form, pension entitlements acquired abroad or in Germany, and business assets or an investment sum as possible bases.

Berlin’s immigration authority states its own standard, since 1 July 2025: an applicant over 45 must prospectively be able to have, on reaching 67, either a monthly pension of EUR 1,612.53 (for at least 12 years) or assets of EUR 232,204. Berlin waives the proof for five nationalities, and Vietnam is not among them.

Vietnam does not appear on the lists of bilateral social security agreements published by the German pension insurer and, as of 1 February 2026, the federal labour ministry. Whether Vietnamese contribution years could be accepted as comparable provision was not established.

The weekly bulletin

Leave your email address. We will keep you informed on citizenship by investment, international capital flows and global mobility.

Family and absence

The spouse of a permit holder is entitled to a residence permit under section 30(1) if both spouses are at least 18, the marriage already existed when the holder’s permit was granted and the stay is expected to exceed one year. The requirement of basic German is waived for spouses of section 21 permit holders.

The requirement of living space is also waived for the family under section 29(5), a provision due to cease to have effect on 31 December 2028. A family member’s permit runs no longer than the holder’s.

An unmarried minor child is entitled to a residence permit under section 32 if both parents, or the parent with sole custody, hold a residence permit for gainful employment, section 21 included, or another listed title.

A child aged 16 or over who does not move to Germany with the parents must have a command of German or appear able to integrate. That condition does not apply where a parent, or the parent’s spouse living with them, holds a section 21 permit.

Under section 51, a residence title lapses if the holder leaves for a reason that is not temporary by nature, or leaves and does not return within six months or a longer period the foreigners authority sets. Towards the five years, at most six months are credited for each stay outside Germany that did not end the permit.

Tax

A person who keeps and uses a dwelling in Germany, or stays there continuously for more than six months, is fully liable to German income tax.

Freelance income is income from independent work, and the Income Tax Act excludes liberal professions from the definition of a trade or business. This means income from an activity that is a liberal profession under that Act falls outside trade tax, which applies to a trade or business.

Taking up freelance work must be reported to the tax office within one month.

Applying from Vietnam

Vietnam is not on the list of nationalities that may enter visa-free for a long stay and apply inside Germany, so a national visa must be issued before entry. Self-employment is not among the categories that the visa service provider takes.

Applicants file by province of habitual residence. The embassy in Hanoi serves a listed group of northern and north-central provinces, down to Thua Thien-Hue, and the consulate general in Ho Chi Minh City the listed central and southern provinces.

The national visa fee is EUR 75 (EUR 37.50 for applicants under 18), paid in dong and not refunded if the application is refused or withdrawn. In principle, applicants must submit the application in person.

The local foreigners authority in Germany takes part whatever the intended length of stay. The Foreign Office says national visas for longer stays take, depending on the purpose, several months.

Hanoi’s appointment page says appointments for all visa categories are allocated through a waiting list. The missions’ self-employment checklist is written for company founders, with a business plan and a commercial-register extract. No freelance-specific checklist was found.

Germany objected to Vietnam’s accession to the Apostille Convention on 20 May 2026, so the Convention does not apply between the two.

The embassy says Vietnamese documents generally have to be legalised for German authorities, after pre-certification by Vietnam’s foreign ministry. The fee for the legalisation endorsement is EUR 30, paid in cash in dong. The embassy advises checking first whether the German authority insists on legalisation.

Legalisation is offered for eight listed types of document: birth, marriage and death certificates, certificates of single status, paternity acknowledgements, residence certificates, divorce judgments and criminal records. Other documents cannot be legalised, and a German translation goes with each document. Diplomas are not on the list; the self-employment checklist asks for qualification documents in the original with a notarised German translation.

No digital nomad category

The Residence Act and the Foreign Office’s visa handbook have no digital nomad category. The programme’s summary page files the section 21(5) freelance permit under that category.

What this article has not established

The standard term of a first freelance permit, the waiting time for appointments, the date of Hanoi’s waiting-list notice (the page ends with “Stand: April 2024”), the pension standards of authorities other than Berlin’s, and whether the EUR 30 legalisation fee is charged per document were not established.

Whether a Germany–Vietnam tax treaty applies was not verified from an official source. The Vietnamese side, pre-certification and tax residence, was not examined.

The Legation Times writes its content from published documents; nothing here is legal, tax or investment advice. Spotted an error? Send a correction request; for content rights, send a takedown request.

Read next

The weekly bulletin

A weekly bulletin on citizenship by investment, capital flows and global mobility. Leave your email address to receive the latest issue.